Imagine you're a big fan of Minecraft. Or maybe another game like it. You've played it since it came out and watched it evolve over the years. One day, you realize there are two ways to install it—either the classic “legacy” version or the newer Microsoft Store version. But what if we told you some people keep both?
TL;DR
Some gamers install both the legacy and store versions of games like Minecraft to gain flexibility and maximize features. Each version can offer something unique—like better mod support or smoother updates. However, managing two installs can also be confusing or take up extra space. It's worth doing in specific use cases like testing, modding, or network play.
Why Keep Two Versions?
It might sound bizarre at first. Why would someone want the same game installed twice? But there are a few surprisingly good reasons to do so:
- Better Compatibility: Some legacy versions are better at running certain mods or community features.
- Exclusive Features: Store versions may have built-in cross-play or easier controller support.
- Separation: Two installs let you experiment or switch profiles without messing things up.
Understanding the Versions
Let’s use Minecraft as our case study. There are generally three types of install:
- Legacy Installer – The classic Java Edition downloaded from Minecraft.net.
- Microsoft Store Version – Also known as Minecraft Bedrock Edition. Found in the Windows Store.
- Lunar or Other Launchers – Custom launchers like Lunar or Badlion offer unique mods and UI tweaks.
Players who love mods usually stick with the legacy Java version. Why? Because Java allows deep customization. You can change textures, gameplay mechanics, and even the way blocks behave.
On the other hand, the Microsoft Store version is polished. Updates are automatic, multiplayer is easier, and it plays nice with consoles and mobile devices.
The Pros of Having Both
Here's why gamers choose to keep both:
1. Modding vs. Multiplayer
The Java (legacy) version thrives on mods. Hardcore players craft huge modpacks. Think Pixelmon or SkyFactory. These aren’t available on the Store version.
The Store version, however, shines when playing with friends on Xbox, Switch, or mobile. It supports crossplay and is more “plug and play.”
2. Updates & Stability
The Store version often gets updates a bit sooner. They’re smoother and auto-installed. Java legacy updates are sometimes more delayed or require reinstallation.
3. Trying New Things
Having two versions means you can keep one “safe” and experiment on the other. Break things, test mechanics, or try different shaders—all without fear.
The Pitfalls of Two Versions
Of course, it’s not all magic and fun. There are drawbacks. Here’s what to watch out for:
1. Disk Space
Each game install can take up gigabytes. Between core files, mods, and saves, things add up fast. You’ll need a computer with plenty of space.
2. Confusion
If you’re not careful, you might forget which version does what. Mods in the wrong folder? Wrong shortcut? Settings gone? Yep—it can get messy.
3. Sync Issues
Cloud saving is limited per version. What you build in one might not carry over to the other. Keep your save files organized!
When It’s Worth Doing
So, is it for everyone? Not really. But it makes a lot of sense in these cases:
- You’re a mod enthusiast and need Java for total control, but also want Bedrock’s smoothness.
- You develop mods or resource packs and need to test them in different environments.
- You share a device—one version could be for a sibling or another profile.
- You’re part of multiple communities—some run Java servers, others use Bedrock Realms.
Tips for Managing Two Versions Smoothly
To make sure things don’t spiral into chaos, here are some smart practices:
- Label your shortcuts. Call one “Minecraft Java” and the other “Minecraft Store.” Simple but effective.
- Use separate folders for mods and saves. Don’t mix them!
- Stick to one version for each project. Don’t try to move worlds across unless you're ready for errors.
- Backup regularly. You don’t want corruption wiping out your mega base.
What About Other Games?
Minecraft isn’t the only game where this happens. Other popular titles also offer legacy and store versions:
- Skyrim: Some prefer the Steam version, others use the Xbox app version for ease of access.
- The Sims 4: Available from EA’s launcher, Steam, and Microsoft Store—with different mod support rules.
- Terraria: Players keep both GOG and Steam versions for modding and multiplayer purposes.
In each case, legacy versions often offer deeper access to the game files. The store editions, however, usually have better integration with cloud saves, achievements, and hardware support like controllers.
Final Thoughts
For some, keeping two installers is a no-brainer. For others, it’s not worth the hassle. It all depends on what you like to do in the game.
If you live for mods, community tweaks, or game hacking, then you want that legacy flexibility. If you enjoy smooth menus, controller play, and fewer crashes, the store version makes sense.
Having both? Well, that gives you the best of both worlds.
Just don’t forget to clean up your shortcuts—and your desktop!
